Working With Veterans and First Responders: Strength, Service, and the Hidden Cost
By: Tyler VanAllen MA, LPC, ESMHL
Veterans and first responders—military personnel, police officers, firefighters, EMTs, paramedics, dispatchers—are often described as “built different.” And in many ways, they are.
These are people who run toward danger when others run away. They train their nervous systems to stay functional under chaos, threat, and human suffering. They carry responsibility not just for their own lives, but for the lives of strangers.
As a therapist, working with this population is both an honor and a challenge—because the very traits that help them survive and succeed on the job can quietly interfere with healing when the uniform comes off.
The Personality Traits That Help Them Thrive
Many veterans and first responders share a cluster of traits that make them effective in high-stress roles:
High responsibility and reliability
They show up. They follow through. People depend on them.Emotional compartmentalization
They can put feelings “on the shelf” in order to act decisively.Mission-first mindset
The task, the team, and the greater good come before personal comfort.Self-sacrifice and endurance
Pain, fear, exhaustion—these are things to push through, not pause for.Strong loyalty and identity tied to service
Their role isn’t just a job; it’s part of who they are.
These traits save lives. They hold systems together. They allow functioning in situations that would overwhelm most people.
But therapy asks for something very different.
When Strength Becomes the Barrier
What works in emergencies often works against healing.
In therapy, the goal isn’t to suppress, override, or outwork emotions. The goal is to notice them, understand them, and integrate them. For many veterans and first responders, that feels unnatural, unsafe, or even irresponsible.
Common barriers include:
Putting feelings last—automatically
Many have been trained, explicitly or implicitly, that their emotional needs come second—or not at all. Over time, this becomes reflexive.Belief that “others have it worse”
Suffering is minimized because someone else survived less, lost more, or didn’t come home.Fear of burdening others
They’re used to being the helper, not the one needing help.Loss of identity without the role
Injury, retirement, or burnout can create a terrifying question: Who am I if I’m not useful?Distrust of vulnerability
In high-risk environments, emotional openness can feel dangerous. That instinct doesn’t turn off easily.
None of this means they are resistant or unwilling. It means their nervous systems learned survival strategies that worked—sometimes brilliantly—under extreme conditions.
Moral Injury: When the Wound Is Ethical, Not Just Emotional
Beyond trauma and stress, many veterans and first responders carry something harder to name: moral injury.
Moral injury occurs when a person experiences, witnesses, or is forced to participate in actions that deeply conflict with their values or sense of right and wrong. Unlike PTSD, which is rooted in fear and threat, moral injury is rooted in guilt, shame, grief, or betrayal.
Examples can include:
Being unable to save someone despite doing everything “right”
Following orders or protocols that resulted in harm
Witnessing systemic failures that contradict personal ethics
Feeling betrayed by leadership, institutions, or the public they served
Surviving when others did not
Because moral injury attacks a person’s identity and values, it often stays hidden. Many feel they have no right to speak about it, or fear judgment if they do. The pain is often carried silently as self-blame, emotional numbness, anger, or a deep sense of disconnection.
In therapy, moral injury is not treated by reframing or “thinking positively.” Healing requires space to grieve, to make meaning, and to rebuild a sense of integrity without excusing harm or dismissing responsibility. It is slow, respectful work; work that acknowledges that some wounds are about who a person believes they are, not just what they experienced.
Therapy Isn’t About Weakness. It’s About Recalibration.
For this population, effective therapy is not about “breaking down defenses.” It’s about honoring why those defenses existed in the first place.
Healing work often looks like:
Learning that rest is not failure
Understanding that emotions are signals, not threats
Separating worth from usefulness
Rebuilding a relationship with the body and nervous system
Allowing care to move in both directions
Progress may be slow and nonlinear. Trust may take time. Silence may carry meaning. A skilled therapist working with veterans and first responders understands that resilience and injury often coexist.
A Different Definition of Strength
Many veterans and first responders come into therapy believing strength means pushing through alone.
Over time, the work often becomes about redefining strength as:
Knowing when to stand down
Letting someone else carry the load
Facing internal pain with the same courage once used externally
The goal isn’t to take away what made them effective; it’s to make room for a life where service doesn’t require self-erasure.
Final Thoughts
Veterans and first responders don’t need to be fixed. They need to be met with respect, cultural understanding, and patience.
The same qualities that once kept them alive may now be asking for an update; not to disappear, but to evolve.
And healing, when it happens, is not a betrayal of who they were.
It’s a continuation of the same mission—just turned inward.
Check out the podcast at